One Million Dollars: A Lot of Chocolate for a Company Director

By
Joe Kafrouni
26 Feb 2013
•
5
min read

The introduction last year of laws making company directors personally liable for their company’s outstanding PAYG and superannuation, and the subsequent collapse of Darrell Lea under a fortnight later, is a great reminder of the onerous commitment made when accepting a company directorship.

Directors must appreciate that they are putting their house (and everything else they own for that matter) on the line when taking on that position. In the case of Darrell Lea, the directors were certainly mindful of their potential personal liability in making the decision to meet with administrators who ultimately put this historical company into administration.

For emphasis, just consider the potential personal liability of a director of Darrell Lea for superannuation alone. It is reported that Darrell Lea had 700 employees. If the Australian Bureau of Statistics is to be believed, an average Australian wage is $55,000 per year. This amounts to an annual wage bill for the company of $38,500,000 a year or $9,625,000 per quarter. The quarterly super bill alone, based on the rate of nine percent of wages, is $866,250. This meant that if the directors of Darrell Lea did not put the company into administration, they would each be potentially liable for almost a million dollars in personal liability, just for superannuation. This is not to mention PAYG and all the other debts being incurred by the company. That’s a lot of chocolate!

In addition to PAYG and super, a company director could be personally liable for all its company’s debts if the company is trading whilst insolvent i.e. the company is incurring debt  whilst unable to pay them when due. Therefore, just like Darrell Lea, a director must stop their company from trading if it is unable to meet its debts. This usually means the company is put into administration of liquidation, a formal legal process.

The question to be posed to ascertain whether a company is insolvent is this: Is the company able to pay all of its debts as and when they become due and payable? To help, company directors should watch out for the following as signs of insolvency:

  1. continuing financial losses;
  2. bills being paid outside supplier trading terms;
  3. tax liabilities not being paid;
  4. supply terms being changed to cash on delivery “COD” terms;
  5. increasingly receiving letters of demands, solicitors’ letters and legal demands;
  6. large number of customers not paying their accounts on time;
  7. no up to date and accurate financial information;
  8. company cheques being dishonoured;
  9. knock-backs on finance applications; and
  10. excessive reliance on family members and friends.

Just remember the old saying: “where there is smoke, there’s fire”. As a director, keep your nose clear so you can smell the smoke. If you smell any, investigate. If it’s serious, or if there is any doubt, call your accountant or solicitor for guidance. That call could save you the roof over your head!

Want my view on your own situation?

Book an initial consultation

: up to two hours with me by phone for a fixed fee of $1,650 (including GST), then a short written note of my advice and next steps. If my conflict check means I can't act, I'll refund your fee in full. To check anything first, email

info@klaw.com.au

or call

(07) 3103 3199

.

Joe Kafrouni, Accredited Specialist in Business Law, Kafrouni Law

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Before acting on it, get advice on your own circumstances. To the extent the law allows, Kafrouni Law accepts no liability for any loss arising from reliance on it. This article is the copyright of Kafrouni Law.

What People Say

Joe's been our company’s lawyer from the beginning and has been instrumental in our journey as company owners and directors. When dealing with both complex and sensitive company issues, Joe is able to provide us with clearly articulated strategies that are well thought‐out and with the bigger picture in mind. He genuinely cares and is always willing to share his personal views, which are both honest and just. Joe is highly professional and knowledgeable in his field. You will definitely benefit having him on your team.

Company director and shareholder

Joe has assisted us with numerous acquisitions and mergers over the last 10 years. Joe's advice and expertise have been invaluable. Joe is always prompt and professional and answers all of our questions in detail. I can highly recommend working with Kafrouni Law and we will look forward to working with them for many years to come.

Managing director, acquisitions

Thank you, Joe. It was a pleasure working with you to resolve the matter today. In particular, I appreciated your patience to fully understand each party’s position and to bed down a final heads of agreement to conclude the resolution between the parties.

Business owner, commercial dispute

Kafrouni Lawyers assisted me to resolve my partnership and company shareholder dispute over a family cattle business and property. From the start, Joe provided practical advice and options to resolve the dispute away from the courts. His perseverance and technical skill helped unravel a complex financial structure, resolved disputed shareholder claims, and resulted in a signed settlement deed rather than litigation. Joe cared to explain the legal and financial complexities behind his step by step advice and maintained our focus on the end goal. Joe's involvement certainly improved my family's position and I recommend Joe to anyone finding themselves in similar circumstances.

Partner and shareholder, family agricultural business

The biggest lesson I have learnt from you recently, Joe, is that it pays to have a professional such as yourself on my side to deal with matters that I am unequipped to handle … so I can carry on with the task at hand of building my business! Thanks again, I’ll take pleasure in recommending your services to anyone in need.

Business owner

Joe, as you know we were in a very difficult position with our company before we engaged you as our lawyer and fortunately, even with the odds stacked heavily against us in our shareholders dispute, you managed to pull us through to victory. You are a true credit to the industry not only because of your skilled negotiating tactics but also due to your personable nature, which made us feel comfortable in such a volatile situation.

Company director, shareholder dispute

‍
‍

Book an initial consultation

An initial consultation is the best way for us to find out whether, and how, I can help. It suits business owners and directors facing a decision that matters. You get my considered view of your situation, not just a first impression.

‍

The fee is a fixed $1,650 (including GST). It covers a phone consultation of up to two hours, plus up to one hour of my time to consider the material you send me beforehand and to prepare my written note afterwards. Here is how it works:

1. When you book, you tell me briefly what the matter is about and who else is involved, so I can carry out a conflict check and confirm I’m free to act. If I can’t act for you, I’ll refund your fee in full.

2. I tell you what information and documents I’d like to see, and I consider them before we speak.

3. We talk it through by phone. I give you my initial advice, the options I see and what I’d do in your shoes.

4. Afterwards, I send you a short written note of my advice and the next steps I recommend.

‍

If I can help further, I’ll explain how. If I can’t, I’ll say so. You are under no obligation to engage me further. If your matter needs more than this, I’ll send you a proposal setting out how I can help and an estimate of my fees. No further work starts until you accept it.

‍

I keep only a limited number of consultation times. If none suits you, or you’d like to check anything before booking, email info@klaw.com.au and I’ll do my best to accommodate you.

Skip to main content